Sunday, November 26, 2017

Where We Belong {by Lynn Austin}

** Note:  I received a free copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review.


In the city of Chicago in 1892, the rules and expectations for Victorian women are strict, their roles in life limited.  But sisters Rebecca and Flora Hawes are not typical Victorian ladies.  Their love of adventure and their desire to use their God-given talents have taken them out of society ballrooms and delivered them to the Sinai Desert -- and into the teeth of a sandstorm.  

Accompanied by Soren Petersen, their somber young butler, and Kate Rafferty, a plucky street urchin learning to be their lady's maid, the two women are on a quest across the desert, chasing rumors of an important biblical manuscript.

As the expedition becomes ever more dangerous and uncertain, all four travelers sift through memories and adventures of their past, recalling the events that shaped them and the journeys and providence that brought them to this very time and place.   [synopsis from the back cover]

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 

Lynn Austin is, in general, one of the best authors of Christian fiction out there -- at least, that's the idea I've gotten from hearing about many of her books and reading a few myself.  So I have to say that I was rather disappointed by this one.  


The plot itself isn't too cliché -- the love triangle near the beginning is something you don't see every day in CF, for instance -- but the way it was written did slip into a lot of CF clichés, in my opinion.  For one thing, I know Ms. Austin explains in the author's note that she based the story off two real sisters and that "God knows when the end of our days will be.  We have nothing to fear" was their real motto, but the amount of times she used it got a little bit irksome and cheesy.  The whole "resenting and bucking the conventional rules for Victorian women" thing is valid and all, but still, unfortunately, overdone in this kind of genre.  And, unfortunately, the way the romances were written did get cheesy fairly often.  *SPOILERS!*  (However, I will say that one instance in which she did not slip into a CF cliché was how Soren and Kate actually didn't become a couple.  I think I actually sort of wanted them to, heehee, but it's still neat that Ms. Austin didn't feel the need to incorporate the typical love/hate romance between the two teen characters.  That was refreshing.  And I was SO thankful that when Soren and Kate had to kiss to get out of that tricky situation with the sheikh, she didn't make it some sort of "scales falling from their eyes," "surprisingly captivating" thing.  Bravo!) *END OF SPOILERS*

Future readers should be aware that most of the book is actually comprised of flashbacks, which is fine, but don't think from the back cover that there's actually a whole lot of time spent in the 1892 Egyptian desert.  There is some, but most of it, like I said, is memory-based.  *Minor Spoilers* (Also, be aware that one of the characters falls into the clutches of a pimp and is forced to live at his brothel, but she escapes before she can be sold to a "customer".  So prostitution is a theme for those few chapters, but there's nothing graphic.  And there is mention of another minor character resorting to prostitution and becoming pregnant with an illegitimate child.) *End of Minor Spoilers*


In terms of characters, most of them were pretty good.  But I have to say that Rebecca Hawes drove. me. up. the. waaaalllllllll for most of the book.  Whether she was right a lot of the time or not, she was way too pushy and overbearing and tried to influence Flora at the expense of Flora's own opinions.  Rebecca had a stronger personality than Flora, and if she wanted to help her, I think she should have worked harder at helping her to find her own voice, cheesy though that sounds.  (To be fair, I'm a little passionate about this because I'm more like Flora than Rebecca.)  Also, Rebecca was pretty foolish and spoiled and headstrong as a child (and even as an adolescent).  The way she'd just take off on her own schemes was irresponsible and dangerous.  I know she doesn't want to be treated like a child, but she was a child, and she was a child with a little sister in tow.  

Ack.  There were just several things about her that bugged me. :-P  (Plus, she and Flora seemed to resort to lying a bit much -- like even when it wasn't a life or death situation.  To be fair, I don't know that I would have done any different/better if I was in some of the positions in which they found themselves, but still.)


All of the characters were fairly well-rounded, though.  (The only main character that I felt I didn't really get to know fully was Kate.)  And the subplot of Soren and Gunnar was ADORABLE.  It reminded me a lot of Jack and Crutchie, but perhaps -- dare I say it? -- even cuter?! :) <3

Although I wasn't a huge fan of the writing in this one, there were times when I could still catch a glimpse of Lynn Austin's signature, humorous, endearing turn of phrase, especially in some of the dialogue. :)  This little bit was cute:

"Have you asked Rebecca how she feels about Timothy?" Edmund asked.

"I'm afraid to.  I so hope she finds happiness with him, yet I don't want to see her get hurt.  If she is falling in love with Timothy and he doesn't return her feelings . . . if he is simply leading her along for her money or for any other reason -- "

"I'll murder him," Edmund finished.  

:)

I can't think of much else to say.  Again, it wasn't awful, but it wasn't Ms. Austin's best, either.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 

Have you read any Lynn Austin books?
Do you like Christian fiction at all?



14 comments:

  1. I can't remember if I have read Lynn Austin or not (I usually don't remember the authors) But I've heard a lot of good things about her! :) And Christian Fiction...eh, it depends on the book. Lovely review, Olivia! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. She has some really good ones! You've read "Candle in the Darkness," haven't you? 'Cause that's Lynn Austin. :)

      And about Christian fiction . . . *ahem* Yes, quite. ;-P

      Aww, thanks so much! And thanks for the comment -- it made me happy! :)

      Delete
  2. It sounded pretty good from the blurb! I'm not exactly comfortable with the prostitution bit though...


    I wonder, from what you said about the writing, if this book was ghost-written...

    Catherine
    catherinesrebellingmuse.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Catherine, yeah, the prostitution bit is pretty brief and minor. It does happen with two different characters, not just once, but it's not at all explicit, and, like I said, one of the characters escapes before anything can actually "happen."

      *looks up ghost-writing* Haha, it wasn't terrible, it was just . . . not her best, at all.

      Delete
  3. Nice job with the review, as always :-) Idk if I should read this one . . . probably not.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. D'aww, thank you, m'dear. :) Hehe yeeaaahhh . . . prob'ly not. Especially since you're not a big fan of Christian fiction in general -- I feel like if you're going to read another one it ought to at least be one that's better written. :-P (And just to clarify, Lynn Austin HAS written really good ones!)

      Delete
  4. I think I've only read one Lynn Austin book - Wonderland Creek. I enjoyed that! To be honest, I haven't read much Christian fiction (especially modern romantic kinds)... it's not really my style. :P
    But I do read ones that are specifically recommended to me!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wonderland Creek is a good one! Candle in the Darkness is another great one, and I've heard good things about the rest of that particular trilogy.

      Hehe, you haven't missed THAT much with Christian fiction . . . it has some really good ones, but it has a lot that are not quite the thing, either. ;-P

      But yeah! There are definitely some that are more than worth reading. I'm actually planning a post about that soon, if I can ever get it finished. :)

      Delete
  5. I haven't read this book! Right now I'm reading Austin's Refiner's Fire series, which is reeeeally good, especially the first book. I'd like to read more of her books, it's too bad to hear that this isn't a great one. I liked the excerpt you added though, that was cute :)

    Nice review Olivia!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Miss Woodhouse, AHHHH, the Refiner's Fire series is apparently SO good! I've read the second book (I think it's the second?) and I really, REALLY liked it. Wonderland Creek is also good, and I want to read Hidden Places because I've heard such good things. :)

      Aww, thanks!! I appreciate it :)

      Delete
  6. I've been trying to work my easy through the (extensive) Lynn Austin collection at my church library. Occasionally I ask rather bored or she gets cheesy BUT have you read her Civil War trilogy because it is A+++ like I enjoyed it so much!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yesssss, I've read the second book in the Civil War trilogy and I've heard the other two are amazing, too.

      She does have some really great ones out!

      Delete
  7. I love Lynn Austin books. I've been wanting to read this one; it sounds pretty good! :)
    Thanks for the post!
    -Amaris

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Amaris, I've really liked some of her books! She's a really good author.

      You're most welcome! Thanks for the comment. :)

      Delete

Comments make my day. Seriously. I'd be so happy if you commented. :)

I've gotten really bad about not replying to comments in a timely manner, but it's always my intention to reply eventually, even though it doesn't always happen.