Passing by Samaria {by Sharon Ewell Foster}

First of all, MERRY CHRISTMAS, ALL!!!  I hope your holidays have been wonderful :)

I didn't think I was going to post on Christmas Day, but then I finished this book called Passing by Samaria and all of a sudden I HAD TO WRITE A REVIEW.  I'm going to past here the review I just wrote for Goodreads.  Love to you all!

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 


Guys, I don't even really know how to start.

"In the spring in Mississippi there were perfect days. They were storybook days. . . ."

I picked up this book off my library's sale rack a while ago. I flipped through the first couple of chapters and put it on my shelf, thinking I'd get around to it eventually but not having any clear plans as to when.


Two nights ago (or rather, technically, it was very very early yesterday morning), I was feeling drained. There had been some really difficult situations going on the previous day that were still weighing on me, and I had had a weird sleep schedule for the past number of nights, and I had just seen a movie that was much sadder than I thought it would be. All in all, I was not in the best frame of mind, and even though it was high time to be in bed, I knew I would just lie there awake. So, I decided to pick up a book and try to read a bit. This one caught my eye. The author's dedication on the front page indicate a desire for the book to be a balm for hurting hearts (not quite in those words), and though I seemed to remember having some complaints about the writing from my previous scan of it, I also seemed to remember a "wholesome quality" to it, shall we say. I asked God to use the book to speak some comfort and some healing, to help me get what He wanted me to get out of it, and I started it.


Oh, it's not perfect. I mean, really, is any book ever perfect? (DON'T say the Bible. You know what I meant.) I still had a few (a very few) complaints. But it didn't take long to realize that the good pretty clearly outstrips the bad.

The story takes place in 1919 and centers around a young black woman named Alena, whose near-fairytale life in Mississippi is shattered by a gruesome discovery. This discovery catapults her from her gentle, rural Mississippi home to the modern and bustling Chicago. There she has to come to grips with the new harsh realities that have been forced upon her, and to process for herself questions of racism, bitterness, forgiveness, redemption, family, faith, etc. I can't say a whole lot more than that because #spoilers, but -- just go read it. Just do yourself that favor.

Gugu Mbatha-Raw -- possible Alena?

Sharon Ewell Foster weaves a tale that's atmospheric, unflinching and uncompromising in its depiction of human depravity, yet gentle, light-filled, and not gratuitous. The writing is perhaps too "feeling" at times -- sometimes characters' emotional responses seem somewhat implausible, too soon, too naïve, etc. -- but the book shies away from the cloying clichés of some of the rest of Christian fiction. (Now, there is a romance, of course, and that romance does start out love-hate on one participant's part, but there are extenuating circumstances leading to that love-hate.) Sometimes characters' dialogue or thought processes also seemed repetitive, but that didn't bother me too much. The characters are still fleshed out, believable, unbelievable, likable, dislikable -- Alena, Deac, Pearl, Amos, Miranda, James, Dinah, Bates, Patrice, Evelyn, Jonathan . . . all (uncomfortably, at times) reminiscent of oneself.

The book deals with some very weighty content matter. It contains racism that will make you nauseous, descriptions of the Klan-like practices of "upstanding" town citizens, lynchings, burning, assaults, distorting of God's Word to support barbarism, etc. It contains moral dilemmas that will make you ache for the character because of how many times you've felt that same sense of entrapment. It contains happiness that will make you happy, anger that will make you angry, sorrow that will make you sorry. It contains redemption that will make you want to weep and to smile at the same time. It contains forgiveness that will challenge you and uplift you. It's good, people. In dealing with forgiveness in the face of the (humanly) unforgivable, it deals with one of the most difficult issues to discuss, but which desperately needs to be addressed. One thing I found especially impressive was how Ms. Foster didn't make all the racism/wrong one-sided. Herself a black lady, she doesn't mince words about how racism is wrong, no questions asked, no excuses holding. And it's wrong no matter which ethnicity nurtures it towards which other ethnicity.

Aldis Hodge -- possible James?

The side stories of Deac and Pearl, and of Miranda and Bates (I guess that's less of a side story, though) are excellent. At first, I felt kind of irritated by Deac's and Pearl's constant reappearance in the story, because it seemed distracting, but in the end, it was well-done. MIRANDA AND BATES. WHAAAAAA. I felt bad for Miranda and had difficulty feeling bad for Bates (I know, I KNOW THAT WAS THE POINT, but one is human). And referring to Miranda's and Bates' cohorts as "the one with blue eyes," "the one with grey eyes," "the one who was always afraid," "the one who always agreed", and so forth? Brilliant.

OH, oh, and guys, CHAPTER 35. WHAT ON EARTH. *SPOILERS!* They came to his funeral and they sang "Amazing Grace." And then some of the others joined them and they formed the circle --just w.o.w. I had to read that part twice because GAHH.

Okay, I should leave you. But guys, I just want you to know, this book is worth reading. It's not the best thing you'll ever read in your life (at least, not from a technical standpoint), but it has some of the best lessons and truth in it that you'll ever read in a fictional book, I think.

The dedication says: ". . . I lift this book up to God. . . . May it be everything You want it to be. May it be medicine, food, sweets to Your people, to those who are isolated." Well, for me at least, it was. Oh, it was.


  1. Merry Christmas!! I hope you as well had a lovely day. :)

    Wow, this books looks good! I'm still wanting to read "In My Father's House" soon, by the way. Very soon. :)

    *adds "Passing By Samaria" to to-read list*

    1. I did, thank you, Meredith! :)

      It really is. Ahhhhh, yes, read IMFH!! Both are awesome :D

  2. MERRY CHRISTMAS!!! *throws presents at everyone*

    And this book sounds positively incredible!

    1. *hugs* I hope it was great, Laura!

      Yes, it is!

  3. Replies
    1. Do! It's a little cheesy in parts, as I said, and there is one Scene (that's shown as wrong, but still, it's there), but all in all -- wholeheartedly recommended :)

  4. My library has it! Going to get it tomorrow 😀

    1. Ooh, yay! I do hope you'll enjoy it, Ivy! :D

  5. Aldis Hodge? Methinks I know the man . . . ;-)

    I'd love to read this. Thanks for recommending it!

    (I'm so sad about Carrie Fisher right now. I just can't believe she's gone and we'll never see her as Princess Leia again :-( )

    1. Heehee, I may or may not have had some ulterior motives in casting him… ;)

      Of course!

      (Oh my goodness. I hadn't actually heard that she was gone, but I knew about the heart attack. So then when I saw your comment I rushed to confirm, and -- wow. I almost cried.)

    2. I know. It's awful :'-( I didn't cry, but I just felt really low all afternoon since I heard . . . She was beautiful. The first princess I ever saw--I was only 3 years old when first introduced to Star Wars--and the one I'll always remember. Pride, grace, strength, dynamism, all rolled into one. You can't ask for anything better than that.

  6. Wow. I really want to read this toooo. :D

    ~Miss Meg

  7. Okay, so I have never read this book, but I just had to say that I love how you picked out actors to play the parts if it were made into a movie! I love that idea and it made me want to start doing it too... Random question: how did you find them? The actors, I mean... Because I'm not familiar with very many actors just off the top of my head.

    1. Thanks, Kayla! Ooh, please do -- I'd love to see your dream casts! Well, I've actually got this weird thing with filing away actors' names, so that helps. But also, sometimes I have a face in mind but I can't remember the name, so googling a movie/show that I've seen the person in and then looking at the cast until I find them is helpful. I'm assuming googling a list of the kind of actor/actress you want might help, too?

    2. Well, thank you! Hmmm, that must come in handy for things like this! :) Ah! It's a good idea... Still, I don't watch very many movies... I still think it would work though! Thanks!

    3. No problem! Oh, well, yes, that may cause slight inconvenience, but like you say, it could still work :D

  8. I'm sorry you were going through a hard time, dear. *hugs*

    Your cast looks amazing and I still want to read this. :D

    Happy New Year!

    1. Thanks, love <3 *returns hug*

      Yay! :) HAPPY NEW YEAR!!


Post a Comment

Comments make my day. Seriously. I'd be so happy if you commented. :)

I've gotten really bad about replying in a timely manner, but it's always my intention to do so eventually. (Even though it doesn't always happen. ;))

Popular posts from this blog

My take on the Elsie Dinsmore series.

Romeo and Juliet (2013) {review}

Christian Purity: Things That (Apparently) Need to Be Said